321 DAILYSPACE COAST

Local

Next hearing Dec. 2 in Canaveral Groves quadruple-murder death penalty case

Domenico Gigante has pleaded guilty to killing four people, including his 15-year-old daughter. A judge, not a jury, will decide whether he is sentenced to death, and she put off a ruling Nov. 9 to review more records.

By 321 Daily editorial team
Published

Text graphic reading Dec. 2: the next court hearing in the Canaveral Groves quadruple-murder case, in which the judge has not decided the sentence
AI-generated illustration: a text graphic of the next hearing date reported in the Domenico Gigante case. · 321 Daily / AI-generated illustration

The next hearing in the Canaveral Groves quadruple-murder case is set for Wednesday, Dec. 2, FOX 35 reported. Domenico Gigante has already pleaded guilty to killing four people, including his 15-year-old daughter. Circuit Judge Laura Moody, not a jury, will decide whether he is sentenced to death, and she has not yet ruled.

What happened at the last hearing

Moody heard the state’s evidence on Nov. 9 but did not impose a sentence. FOX 35, whose reporter was in the courtroom, said the judge wanted more information on Gigante’s mental health and school records before ruling, and put off the rest of the sentencing until at least Dec. 2.

Gigante represented himself that day and did not contest the state’s case, the station reported. Moody urged him to accept a lawyer, warning that "it is almost always unwise to represent yourself in court." He declined. "I am going to continue with being pro se and I’m going to continue with the guilty verdict and I’m going to continue with waiving my right to sentencing by a jury," he told the court, according to FOX 35.

The plea

Gigante, 40, a former emergency medical technician, pleaded guilty Aug. 27, the State Attorney’s Office for the 18th Judicial Circuit said in a release that day. State Attorney William Scheiner said the state would continue to seek the death penalty. Because Gigante waived a trial and a jury penalty hearing, the sentence is Moody’s alone to decide.

He had dropped his public defender in July to represent himself, the release said. After the plea, he told the judge, "I’m guilty, and I meet the aggravating factors. I have no interest in appealing." The office said then that sentencing was expected in late October or early November.

The case

According to the State Attorney’s Office, Gigante left his Rockledge home in the early morning of March 1, 2023, drove to a house on Alan Shepard Avenue northwest of Cocoa and broke in while the family slept. He fatally shot his daughter, her mother, her grandmother and the mother’s roommate. Two younger children, ages 6 and 9, were not hurt and called a relative for help after he left, shortly before 2 a.m. Sheriff’s investigators arrested him in Rockledge later that day.

A grand jury indicted him on four counts of first-degree premeditated murder with a firearm and one count of armed burglary with a firearm. In seeking death, prosecutors cited that he committed multiple murders, killed his own daughter, acted in a "cold, calculated and premeditated manner," and did so during a burglary.

The State Attorney’s release does not name the four people who were killed, and this story does not either.

Court dates can change. The Brevard County Clerk of Court’s public calendar is the place to confirm the time and courtroom before Dec. 2.

Based on the State Attorney’s Aug. 27 release and FOX 35’s report from the Nov. 9 hearing. 321 Daily did not attend the hearing and did not seek comment for this story.

Share on FacebookShare by email

The 321 Daily newsletter

Stay connected to Brevard

Local stories, places to try, and useful weekend ideas — in your inbox.

Free to join. Local roundups when new issues are published. Unsubscribe anytime.

Read past editions first →

Follow 321 Daily

Stay connected across the Space Coast.